By: Kendall Jackson, Esq.
Here at The Phia Group, stop-loss policy reviews are an essential part of our consulting service. Over the years, we’ve examined countless policies from a variety of different carriers. The scope of our review is extensive, with the goal of identifying potential gaps and inconsistencies that may cause the plan to face significant liability. One benefit of having the review performed annually (which we would recommend for any group) is the detection of new provisions that slip in at renewal that may or may not be beneficial to the plan. What is perhaps slightly more concerning are the provisions not included at renewal that are ultimately necessary to adequately protect the plan.
A prime example of this occurred after the passage of the Affordable Care Act over a decade ago. For years, stop-loss carriers were slow to incorporate provisions accounting for claims eventually deemed payable through an Independent Review Organization (IRO) determination. The IRO process tends to be quite lengthy since it does not play out until the plan’s internal appeals have been exhausted. As a result, an IRO could order a claim payable well after the end of the applicable stop-loss policy period. This is particularly concerning for plans, as stop-loss policies contain precise timeframes during which claims must be incurred and paid by the plan in order to be eligible for reimbursement. Where a plan ultimately fails to pay the claims during that period, despite it being outside of its control by virtue of the lengthy IRO process, the plan could be left with no potential for stop-loss reimbursement.
Subsequently, the IRO extension was born. The structure of this provision varies from policy to policy, but in most cases, it provides for an extension of the period in which claims can be “paid” if deemed payable by an IRO. The most common extension is twelve months, and an extension of that length affords the plan adequate protection. Extensions shorter than twelve months, whether three or six months, do not properly safeguard the plan since the IRO process can extend well beyond that timeframe. As an alternative to a defined timeframe, we have also seen policies stipulate something to the effect of “claims deemed payable by an IRO will be considered as having been paid during the policy period.” This type of provision is typically conditioned on the satisfaction of certain criteria but is nevertheless a mechanism to provide the plan with sufficient protection. Regardless of the form it takes, an IRO extension is a provision that is vital for plans. While the vast majority of policies contain an IRO extension, there are some carriers who have yet to add in this protection. In such cases, we would highly recommend conferring with the carrier to ensure this provision is added, since it has largely become industry standard for a policy to contain it.
A few years ago, a similar issue developed as a result of the passage of the No Surprises Act (NSA). Similar to an IRO deeming a claim payable well after it was incurred, the NSA provides for an IDR process that may also extend well beyond the applicable policy period. The IDR process functions as a federal arbitration mechanism to resolve disputes between providers and plans for NSA-eligible claims. During the process, the IDR entity reviews the case and makes a determination that may or may not be in favor of the plan. Depending on the determination, the plan may have to pay additional amounts to the provider. The IDR process has historically been subject to significant delays, and if the additional amount paid by the plan is beyond the stop-loss policy’s designated periods, reimbursement may not be available for those amounts.
Once again, a need was identified for a provision within stop-loss policies to account for potential payment delays from the IDR process. Currently, only a handful of carriers have provisions accounting for the delays associated with the IDR process. If carriers operate in a similar manner as they did for the IRO provision, then it may be a while before an IDR provision is industry standard for stop-loss policies. Ideally, these protections would be added as soon as possible, but if history is any indication, the incorporation of the provisions may be slow. That said, given that a provision accounting for the additional amounts required as part of the IDR process would be analogous to the extension afforded to claims deemed payable by an IRO, carriers may be more willing to incorporate this added protection at a faster rate. Where the policy does not contain this provision, we recommend conferring with the carrier to advocate for the addition of this protection.
The absence of these provisions creates issues that highlight the importance of having a gap review performed. The Phia Group can help identify areas of concern and offer suggestions for ways to minimize gaps and the plan’s overall liability. Addressing concerns proactively is the best way to counteract issues that could jeopardize the plan’s financial position.