A self-funded employer enjoys the following benefits:
Plan Control — Choose what to cover and exclude, customizing the plan to be generous where your particular membership needs it, and stingy where it doesn’t.
Interest and CashFlow — Funds are in the employer’s hands until they’re needed, meaning interest accrued from those assets belongs to the employer.
Federal Preemption and Lower Taxes — The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 states that a private, self-funded health plan is administered in accordance with its terms and federal rules. So, these plans aren’t subject to conflicting state health insurance regulations or benefit mandates.
Risk Reduction — Reducing risk and costs directly impacts the employer and employees. Risk posed by other populations doesn’t impact the plan — so employees have lower single and family premiums than those with fully funded insurance.
Overall, a self-funded plan sees net savings over a three-to five-year span, compared to a similar fully funded insurance policy.
Yet, there are risks. Among them are the threat of catastrophic claims, inability to fund claims, and new fiduciary responsibilities to members of the plan.
Most self-funded health plans purchase “stop-loss” — a form of reinsurance that reimburses self-funded plans for claims they pay beyond a deductible. This means the self-funded plan is responsible for all medical bills, regardless of whether stop-loss reimburses or denies the plan’s request.
Finally, a self-funded employer acts as — or appoints — a plan administrator, who is a “fiduciary” of the plan and its members. Law dictates the fiduciary must act prudently, protect the plan and apply its terms judiciously. Failure to comply with these terms, mismanaging plan assets or doing something not in the plan’s best interest could expose the plan sponsor to claims of fiduciary breach — and steep penalties. Fortunately, third-party organizations exist to step in, aid in decision-making and act as a fiduciary — indemnifying the self-funded plan administrator.
Containing costs is important for all health plans — “traditional” fully funded insurance and self-funded — but employers who self-fund their plan in particular may have a fiduciary duty to pursue any and all cost containment opportunities, as they are obligated to prudently manage plan assets.
For this reason, health insurance in all its forms must look for and take advantage of cost containment opportunities whenever possible. One such opportunity comes in the form of subrogation.
Health insurance subrogation is therefore a process that allows insurance and self-funded health plans to shift the liability associated with these expenses to the appropriate party, allowing health plans to maintain their premium levels.
Typical situations where health insurance subrogation may be used to coordinate payment with other payers include car accidents (where automobile insurance may be primarily responsible for payment), work injuries (where workers’ compensation may be primarily responsible), slip and falls (where the property owner’s liability insurance may be responsible), toxic torts, product recalls, and other scenarios where a court has decided someone needs to pay damages, including amounts already paid by the health plan.
Surprisingly, healthcare subrogation is something that tends to be underutilized in the marketplace, but it is a critical tool to keep premiums (when dealing with traditional fully funded insurance) or contributions (when dealing with self-funded plans) low. Many insurance carriers (who manage their own fully funded policies of insurance) and third-party administrators (who administer self-funded plans on behalf of the employer funding the plan), report recovering between $3 and $5 per plan member per year. Subrogation specialists, who are subcontracted by carriers and third-party administrators, report recoveries of about $15 per member per year. The Phia Group, LLC, reports recoveries of $25 per member per year. These funds are returned to the plan, to be used towards future medical expenses, and are amounts that won’t need to be collected from plan members or insureds in the future, via premium or contribution rate increases.
As mentioned, when looking at health plans provided by employers or unions, there is frequently a right of subrogation clause in the plan document or policy. Because self-funded plans need to only comply with federal law, and in particular, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (“ERISA”), they will assert rights in their plan document to recover 100% of the funds they paid, when a third-party payer is responsible for the payment. In situations where this self-funded class of participant is injured, these provisions often allow the benefit plan to make payment contingent upon the plan member agreeing to cooperate with the plan in its effort to recoup funds.
This right on the part of a self-funded plan to collect full reimbursement is due in part to ERISA, but also requires excellent plan document language. Indeed, the plan’s rights are only as good as its language. This system, while complex, aims to tackle the costs of providing robust health benefit plans, while allowing these plans to feel secure paying claims promptly when a third party may be available to pay, knowing that they will be able to recoup those funds later.
On the other hand, as previously mentioned, traditional insurance plans that are funded fully by insurance companies are subject to state laws that regulate the payment of health benefits, including subrogation. If a health plan is fully funded through insurance purchased by the employer or union, it will be treated as any normal group health insurance, regulated by state law, thus impacting whether a subrogation claim is enforceable. These fully insured plans are often looked at with careful scrutiny by state lawmakers and can have specific legal limits that cap options for subrogation on behalf of the insurer.
In addition, as previously mentioned, the overall recovery opportunity may be eliminated entirely depending on state laws. These state-based laws include the made-whole doctrine, common fund doctrine and other anti-subrogation statutes that can influence the insurance recovery process for health payouts. For such insurance carriers, the need to apply creative thinking, up-to-date legal expertise, and excellent negotiation skills is of the utmost importance.
As mentioned previously, a self-funded plan — thanks to ERISA — can enforce the terms of their plan document. As such, the quality of that plan document is the key to success when it comes to subrogation. Subrogation begins, therefore, when the plan document is being drafted. By the time a person is hurt, claims are paid, and a liable third party is being pursued for reimbursement, it’s too late to address weaknesses in the plan document. For instance, while a traditional fully funded insurance carrier’s right to subrogation may be limited by a state law rule — such as the Made Whole Doctrine (which states that the insurance carrier may recoup nothing unless and until the injured insured individual is fully compensated for their damages) — a self-funded plan is not required to comply with this doctrine, as long as it is explicitly disclaimed in the plan document. A failure to disclaim equates to a requirement to comply.
Finding unique opportunities related to the recovery of funds may be critical in making sure benefit plans are fully reimbursed, and only ultimately pay claims for which they are actually responsible. If you’re looking for methods to get the recovery amount that is justified, the option to work with specialists such as The Phia Group, LLC and others is a worthwhile venture.
Learn more about our subrogation and recovery services today.